Chapter 25The Origin and Diversification of Eukaryotes
Key Concepts
25.1 Eukaryotes Acquired Features from Both Archaea and Bacteria
25.2 Major Lineages of Eukaryotes Diversified in the Precambrian
25.3 Protists Reproduce Sexually and Asexually
25.4 Protists Are Critical Components of Many Ecosystems
A bloom of dinoflagellates of the genus Noctiluca was responsible for this red tide in Puget Sound in the U.S. state of Washington.
© Don Paulson/PureStock/AGE Fotostock
Investigating Life: Predicting Toxic Red Tides
In summer 2005, a devastating red tide crippled the shellfish industry along the Atlantic coast of North America from Canada to Massachusetts. This red tide was produced by a bloom of dinoflagellates of the genus Alexandrium. These protists produce a powerful toxin that accumulates in clams, mussels, and oysters. A person who eats a mollusk contaminated with the toxin can experience a syndrome known as paralytic shellfish poisoning. Many people were sickened by eating mollusks that were harvested before the problem was diagnosed, and losses to the shellfish industry in 2005 were estimated at $50 million.
Several species of dinoflagellates produce toxic red tides in many parts of the world. Along the Gulf of Mexico, red tides caused by dinoflagellates of the genus Karenia produce a neurotoxin that affects the central nervous systems of fishes, which become paralyzed and cannot respire effectively. Huge numbers of dead fishes wash up on Gulf Coast beaches during a Karenia red tide. In addition, wave action can produce aerosols of the Karenia toxin, and these aerosols often cause asthma-like symptoms in humans on shore.
After the losses that resulted from the 2005 red tide, biologists at the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI) on Cape Cod began to monitor and model dinoflagellate populations off the New England coast. If biologists could accurately forecast future blooms, people in the area could be made aware of the problem in advance and adjust the shellfish harvest (and their eating habits) accordingly.
Biologists from WHOI monitored counts of dinoflagellates in the water and in seafloor sediments. They also monitored river runoff, water currents, water temperature and salinity, winds, and tides. An additional environmental factor was the “nor’easter” storms common along the New England coast. By correlating their measurements of these environmental factors with dinoflagellate counts, biologists produced a model that predicted growth of dinoflagellate populations.
In spring 2008, the WHOI team determined that all the factors were in place to produce another red tide like the one of 2005—if a nor’easter occurred to blow the dinoflagellates toward the coast. A nor’easter did occur at just the wrong time, and another red tide materialized in summer 2008, just as predicted. But this time, people were warned. Shellfish harvesters adjusted their harvest, and many fewer people were harmed by eating toxic mollusks.
QA Red tides are harmful, but how are dinoflagellates beneficial to marine ecosystems? (Find the answer on page 578.)
Eukaryotes Acquired Features from Both Archaea and Bacteria
Eukaryotes Acquired Features from Both Archaea and Bacteria
Learning Objectives
25.1.1 Explain the use of the term “protist” and describe the relationships of major protist groups to other eukaryotes.
25.1.2 List the five key events that led to the evolution of eukaryotes from a prokaryotic ancestor, and know how these events allowed for the establishment of unique cellular functions.
25.1.3 Explain how major changes in Earth’s environment affected the evolution of the eukaryotic cell.
25.1.4 Classify the history of genes in a eukaryotic cell based on whether their origins are nuclear, mitochondrial, or chloroplastic.
We easily recognize trees, mushrooms, and insects as plants, fungi, and animals, respectively. But there is a dazzling assortment of other eukaryotic organisms—many microscopic, but some, like kelp, which grow very large—that do not fit into these three groups. Eukaryotes that are not plants, animals, or fungi have traditionally been called protists. But phylogenetic analyses reveal that many of the groups we commonly refer to as protists are not, in fact, closely related. Thus the term “protist” does not describe a monophyletic group, but is a term of convenience for “all the eukaryotes that are not plants, animals, or fungi.”
The unique characteristics of the eukaryotic cell lead scientists to conclude that the eukaryotes are monophyletic, and that a single eukaryotic ancestor diversified into the many different protist lineages as well as giving rise to the plants, fungi, and animals. As we saw in Key Concept 24.1, eukaryotes are a specialized group of archaea that acquired a cell nucleus. The mitochondria and chloroplasts of eukaryotes, however, are clearly derived from bacterial lineages (see Figure 24.1).
Biologists have hypothesized that the origin of eukaryotes from a specialized archaeal ancestor was followed by the endosymbioses with bacterial lineages that led to the origin of mitochondria and chloroplasts. Some biologists prefer to view the origin of eukaryotes as the fusion of lineages from the two prokaryotic groups. This difference is largely a semantic one that hinges on the subjective point at which we deem the eukaryotic lineage to have become definitively “eukaryotic.” In either case, we can make some reasonable inferences about the events that led to the evolution of a new cell type, bearing in mind that the environment underwent an enormous change—from low to high availability of free atmospheric oxygen ()—during the course of these events.
The modern eukaryotic cell arose in several steps
Several events were important in the origin of the modern eukaryotic cell (Figure 25.1):
The origin of a flexible cell surface
The origin of a cytoskeleton
The origin of a nuclear envelope, which enclosed a genome organized into chromosomes
The appearance of digestive vacuoles
The acquisition of mitochondria and chloroplasts via endosymbiosis
FLEXIBLE CELL SURFACE We presume that ancient prokaryotic organisms, like most present-day prokaryotic cells, had firm cell walls. The first step toward the eukaryotic condition was the loss of the cell wall by an archaean. This wall-less condition occurs in some present-day prokaryotes.
Consider the possibilities open to a flexible cell without a firm wall, starting with cell size. As a cell grows larger, its surface area-to-volume ratio decreases (see Figure 5.2). Unless the surface area can be increased, the cell volume will reach an upper limit. If the cell’s surface is flexible, however, it can fold inward and become more elaborate, creating more surface area for gas and nutrient exchange. With a surface flexible enough to allow infolding, the cell can exchange materials with its environment rapidly enough to sustain a larger volume and more rapid metabolism (see Figure 25.1, steps 1–2). Furthermore, a flexible surface can pinch off bits of the environment, bringing them into the cell by endocytosis. These infoldings of the cell surface, which also exist in some modern prokaryotes, were important for the evolution of large eukaryotic cells.
CHANGES IN CELL STRUCTURE AND FUNCTION Other early steps that were important for the evolution of the eukaryotic cell involved increased compartmentalization and complexity of the cell (see Figure 25.1, steps 3–7):
- The development of a more complex cytoskeleton
- The formation of ribosome-studded internal membranes, some of which surrounded the DNA
- The enclosure of the cell’s DNA in a nucleus
- The formation of a flagellum from microtubules of the cytoskeleton
- The evolution of digestive vacuoles
Until a few years ago, biologists thought that cytoskeletons were restricted to eukaryotes. Improved imaging technology and molecular analyses have now revealed homologs of many cytoskeletal proteins in prokaryotes, so simple cytoskeletons evolved before the origin of eukaryotes. The cytoskeleton of a eukaryote, however, is much more developed and complex than that of a prokaryote. This greater development of microfilaments and microtubules supports the eukaryotic cell and allows it to manage changes in shape, to distribute daughter chromosomes, and to move materials from one part of its larger cell to other parts. In addition, the presence of microtubules in the cytoskeleton allowed some cells to develop the characteristic eukaryotic flagellum.
The DNA of a prokaryotic cell is attached to a site on its cell membrane. If that region of the cell membrane were to fold into the cell, the first step would be taken toward the evolution of a nucleus, a primary feature of the eukaryotic cell. The nuclear envelope appeared early in the eukaryotic lineage. The next step was probably phagocytosis—the ability to engulf and digest other cells.
Figure 25.1 Evolution of the Eukaryotic Cell The loss of a firm cell wall allowed the cell membrane to fold inward and create more surface area, which facilitated the evolution of larger cells. As cells grew larger, cytoskeletal complexity increased, and the cell became increasingly compartmentalized. Endosymbioses involving bacteria gave rise to mitochondria and (in photosynthetic eukaryotes) to chloroplasts. Q: How could you use DNA sequencing and phylogenetic analysis to test the endosymbiotic origins hypothesis for mitochondria and chloroplasts?
ENDOSYMBIOSIS At the same time the processes we have just outlined were taking place, cyanobacteria were generating oxygen as a product of photosynthesis. The increasing concentrations of oxygen in the oceans, and eventually in the atmosphere, had disastrous consequences for most organisms of the time, which were unable to tolerate the newly oxidizing environment. But some prokaryotes evolved strategies to use the increasing oxygen, and—fortunately for us—so did some of the new phagocytic eukaryotes.
At about this time, endosymbiosis began to play a role in eukaryotic evolution (see Figure 25.1, steps 8–9). The theory of endosymbiosis proposes that certain organelles are the descendants of prokaryotes engulfed, but not digested, by ancient eukaryotic cells. One crucial event in the history of eukaryotes was the incorporation of a proteobacterium that evolved into the mitochondrion. Initially the new organelle’s primary function was probably to detoxify by reducing it to water. Later this reduction became coupled with the formation of ATP in cellular respiration. After this step, the essential eukaryotic cell was complete.
Connect the Concepts You may wish to review the reactions of cellular respiration in Key Concept 5.3.
Photosynthetic eukaryotes are the result of yet another endosymbiotic step: the incorporation of a prokaryote related to today’s cyanobacteria, which became the chloroplast.
Chloroplasts have been transferred among eukaryotes several times
Eukaryotes in several different groups possess chloroplasts, and groups with chloroplasts appear in several distantly related eukaryotic clades. Some of these groups differ in the photosynthetic pigments their chloroplasts contain. And not all chloroplasts are limited to a pair of surrounding membranes—in some microbial eukaryotes, chloroplasts are surrounded by three or more membranes. We now view these observations as evidence of a remarkable series of endosymbioses. This conclusion is supported by extensive evidence from electron microscopy and nucleic acid sequence comparisons.
All chloroplasts trace their ancestry back to the engulfment of one cyanobacterium by a larger eukaryotic cell. This event, the step that first gave rise to the photosynthetic eukaryotes, is known as primary endosymbiosis (Figure 25.2A). The cyanobacterium, a Gram-negative bacterium, had both an inner and an outer membrane (see Figure 24.2B). Thus the original chloroplasts had two surrounding membranes: the inner and outer membranes of the cyanobacterium. Remnants of the peptidoglycan-containing cell wall of the bacterium are present in the form of a bit of peptidoglycan between the chloroplast membranes of glaucophytes, the first eukaryotic group to branch off following primary endosymbiosis (as we will see in Chapter 26). Primary endosymbiosis also gave rise to the chloroplasts of the red algae, green algae, and land plants. The red algal chloroplast retains certain pigments of the original cyanobacterial endosymbiont that are absent in green algal chloroplasts.
Figure 25.2 Endosymbiotic Events in the Evolution of Chloroplasts (A) A single instance of primary endosymbiosis ultimately gave rise to all of today’s chloroplasts. (B) Secondary endosymbiosis—the uptake and retention of a chloroplast-containing cell by another eukaryotic cell—took place several times, independently. Animation 25.1 Family Tree of Chloroplasts
Almost all remaining photosynthetic eukaryotes are the result of additional rounds of endosymbiosis. For example, the photosynthetic euglenids derived their chloroplasts from secondary endosymbiosis (Figure 25.2B). Their ancestor took up a unicellular green alga, retaining its chloroplast and eventually losing the rest of the constituents of the alga. This history explains why the photosynthetic euglenids have the same photosynthetic pigments as the green algae and land plants. It also accounts for the third membrane of the euglenoid chloroplast, which is derived from the euglenid’s cell membrane (as a result of endocytosis). An additional round of endosymbiosis—tertiary endosymbiosis—occurred when a dinoflagellate apparently lost its chloroplast and took up another protist that had acquired its chloroplast through secondary endosymbiosis.
Recap and Assess
The modern eukaryotic cell probably arose from an ancestral prokaryotic archaean in several steps, including the origin of a flexible cell surface and the enclosure of the genetic material in a nucleus. Later, endosymbioses of proteobacteria and cyanobacteria led to the origins of mitochondria and chloroplasts, respectively.
- Why was the development of a flexible cell surface a key event for eukaryotic evolution?
- Explain how increased availability of atmospheric oxygen () could have influenced the evolution of the eukaryotic cell.
Background for Questions 3–4: Ribosomal RNA (rRNA) genes are present in the nuclear genome of eukaryotes. There are also rRNA genes in the genomes of mitochondria and chloroplasts. Therefore photosynthetic eukaryotes have three different sets of rRNA genes, which encode the structural RNA of three separate sets of ribosomes. The gene tree below shows the evolutionary relationships among rRNA gene sequences isolated from the nuclear genomes of humans, yeast, and corn; from a prokaryotic archaean (Halobacterium), a proteobacterium (E. coli), and a cyanobacterium (Chlorobium); and from the mitochondrial and chloroplast genomes of corn.
- Why are the three rRNA genes of corn not one another’s closest relatives?
- How would you explain the closer relationship of the mitochondrial rRNA gene of corn to the rRNA gene of E. coli than to the nuclear rRNA genes of other eukaryotes? Can you explain the relationship of the rRNA gene from the chloroplast of corn to the rRNA gene of the cyanobacterium?
- Explain why the term “protists” does not refer to a formal taxonomic group.
The features that eukaryotes gained from prokaryotic archaea and bacteria have allowed them to exploit many different environments. This led to the evolution of great diversity among eukaryotes, beginning with a radiation that started in the Precambrian.
Major Lineages of Eukaryotes Diversified in the Precambrian
Learning Objectives
- 25.2.1 Distinguish among the major groups of microbial eukaryotes (alveolates, stramenopiles, rhizarians, excavates, and amoebozoans).
- 25.2.2 Justify the position that it is relatively easy for multicellularity to evolve.
- 25.2.3 Elaborate on why protists are important to our medical and economic concerns.
Most eukaryotes can be placed in one of eight major clades that began to diversify about 1.5 billion years ago: alveolates, stramenopiles, rhizarians, excavates, and amoebozoans.
opiles, rhizarians, excavates, plants, amoebozoans, fungi, and animals (Figure 25.3). Plants, fungi, and animals each have close protist relatives (such as the choanoflagellate relatives of animals), which we will discuss along with those major multicellular eukaryotic groups in Chapters 26–31.
Each of the five major groups of protist eukaryotes covered in this chapter consists of organisms with enormously diverse body forms and nutritional lifestyles. Some protists are motile, whereas others do not move. Some protists are photosynthetic, whereas others are heterotrophic. Most protists are unicellular, but some are multicellular. Most protists are microscopic, but a few are huge (giant kelps, for example, can grow to half the length of a football field). We refer to the unicellular species of protists as microbial eukaryotes, but keep in mind that there are large, multicellular protists as well.
Multicellularity has arisen dozens of times across the evolutionary history of eukaryotes. Four of the origins of multicellularity resulted in large organisms that are familiar to most people: plants, animals, fungi, and brown algae (the last are a group of stramenopiles). In addition, there are dozens of smaller and less familiar groups among the eukaryotes that include multicellular species. Recent experimental studies have shown that artificial selection for multicellularity can produce repeated, convergent evolution of multicellular forms over just a few months in some normally unicellular eukaryotic species. In addition, many unicellular species retain individual identities but nonetheless associate in large multicellular colonies. There is a near-continuum between fully integrated, multicellular organisms on the one hand and loosely integrated multicellular colonies of cells on the other. Biologists do not always agree on where to draw the line between the two.
Figure 25.3 Precambrian Divergence of Major Eukaryotic Groups A phylogenetic tree shows a current hypothesis and estimated time line for the origin of the major groups of eukaryotes. The rapid divergence of major lineages between 1.5 and 1.4 billion years ago (bya) makes reconstruction of their precise relationships difficult. The major multicellular groups (tinted boxes) will be covered in subsequent chapters.
Biologists used to classify protists largely on the basis of their life histories and reproductive features. In recent years, however, electron microscopy and gene sequencing have revealed many new patterns of evolutionary relatedness among these groups. Analyses of slowly evolving gene sequences are making it possible to explore evolutionary relationships among eukaryotes in ever greater detail and with greater confidence. Nonetheless, some substantial areas of uncertainty remain, and lateral gene transfer may complicate efforts to reconstruct the evolutionary history of protists (as was also true for prokaryotes; see Key Concept 24.1). Today we recognize great diversity among the many distantly related protist clades.
Alveolates have sacs under their cell membranes
Alveolates are so named because they possess sacs, called alveoli, just beneath their cell membranes, which may play a role in supporting the cell surface. All alveolates are unicellular, and most are photosynthetic, but they are diverse in body form. The alveolate groups we consider in detail here are the dinoflagellates, apicomplexans, and ciliates.
DINOFLAGELLATES Most dinoflagellates are marine and photosynthetic; they are important primary producers of organic matter in the oceans. Although fewer species of dinoflagellates live in fresh water, individuals can be abundant in freshwater environments. The dinoflagellates are of great ecological, evolutionary, and morphological interest. A distinctive mixture of photosynthetic and accessory pigments gives their chloroplasts a golden brown color. Some dinoflagellate species cause red tides, as discussed at the start of this chapter. Other species are photosynthetic endosymbionts that live within the cells of other organisms, including invertebrate animals (such as corals; see Investigating Life: Can Corals Reacquire Dinoflagellate Endosymbionts Lost to Bleaching?) and other marine protists (see Figure 25.12A). Still others are nonphotosynthetic and live as parasites within other marine organisms.
Dinoflagellates have a distinctive appearance. They generally have two flagella, one in an equatorial groove around the cell, the other starting near the same point as the first and passing down a longitudinal groove before extending into the surrounding medium (Figure 25.4). Some dinoflagellates can take on different forms, including amoeboid ones, depending on environmental conditions. It has been claimed that the dinoflagellate Pfiesteria piscicida can occur in at least two dozen distinct forms, although this claim is highly controversial. In any case, this remarkable dinoflagellate, when present in large enough numbers, is harmful to fishes and can both stun and feed on them.
APICOMPLEXANS The exclusively parasitic apicomplexans derive their name from the apical complex, a mass of organelles contained in the apical end (the tip) of the cell. These organelles help the apicomplexan invade its host’s tissues. For example, the apical complex enables Plasmodium, the causative agent of malaria, to enter its target cells in the human body after transmission by a mosquito.
Figure 25.4 A Dinoflagellate The presence of two flagella is characteristic of many dinoflagellates, although these appendages are contained within deep grooves and thus are seldom visible. One flagellum lies within the equatorial groove and provides forward thrust and spin to the organism. The second flagellum originates in the longitudinal groove and acts like the rudder of a boat.
Like many obligate parasites, apicomplexans have elaborate life cycles featuring asexual and sexual reproduction through a series of very dissimilar life stages (see Figure 25.20). In many species, these life stages are associated with two different types of host organisms, as is the case with Plasmodium. Another apicomplexan, Toxoplasma, alternates between cats and rats to complete its life cycle. A rat infected with Toxoplasma loses its fear of cats, which makes it more likely to be eaten by, and thus transfer the parasite to, a cat.
CILIATES The ciliates are named for their numerous hairlike cilia, which are shorter than, but otherwise identical to, eukaryotic flagella. The ciliates are much more complex in body form than are most other unicellular eukaryotes (Figure 25.5). Their definitive characteristic is the possession of two types of nuclei (whose roles we describe in Key Concept 25.3 when we discuss protist reproduction). Almost all ciliates are heterotrophic, although a few contain photosynthetic endosymbionts.
Paramecium, a frequently studied ciliate genus, exemplifies the complex structure and behavior of ciliates (Figure 25.6). The slipper-shaped cell is covered by an elaborate pellicle, a structure composed principally of an outer membrane and an inner layer of closely packed, membrane-enclosed sacs (the alveoli) that surround the bases of the cilia. Defensive organelles called trichocysts are also present in the pellicle. In response to a threat, a microscopic explosion expels the trichocysts in a few milliseconds, and they emerge as sharp darts, driven forward at the tip of a long, expanding filament.
Figure 25.5 Diversity among the Ciliates (A) A free-swimming organism, this Paramecium belongs to a ciliate group whose members have many cilia of uniform length. (B) The barrel-shaped Didinium nasutum feeds on other ciliates, including Paramecium. Its cilia occur in two separate bands. (C) The parasite Trichodina creates suction with its ring of cilia that help attach it to the surface of a fish host.
The cilia provide Paramecium with a form of locomotion that is generally more precise than locomotion by flagella. A Paramecium can coordinate the beating of its cilia to propel itself either forward or backward in a spiraling manner. It can also back off swiftly when it encounters a barrier or a negative stimulus. The coordination of ciliary beating is probably the result of a differential distribution of ion channels in the cell membrane near the two ends of the cell.
Figure 25.6 Anatomy of Paramecium Paramecium, with its many specialized organelles, exemplifies the complex body form of ciliates. Activity 25.1 Anatomy of Paramecium
Organisms living in fresh water are hypertonic to their environment. Many freshwater protists, including Paramecium, address this problem by means of specialized contractile vacuoles that excrete the excess water the organisms constantly take in by osmosis. The excess water collects in the contractile vacuoles, which then contract and expel the water from the cell.
Paramecium and many other protists engulf solid food by endocytosis, forming a digestive vacuole within which the food is digested (Figure 25.7). Smaller vesicles containing digested food pinch away from the digestive vacuole and enter the cytosol. These tiny vesicles provide a large surface area across which the products of digestion can be absorbed by the rest of the cell.
Animation 25.2 Digestive Vacuoles
Stramenopiles typically have two unequal flagella, one with hairs
A morphological synapomorphy of most stramenopiles is the possession of rows of tubular hairs on the longer of their two flagella. Some stramenopiles lack flagella, but they are descended from ancestors that possessed flagella. The stramenopiles include the diatoms and the brown algae, which are photosynthetic, and the oomycetes, which are not.
DIATOMS All of the diatoms are unicellular, although some species associate in filaments. Many have sufficient carotenoids in their chloroplasts to give them a yellow or brownish color. All of them synthesize carbohydrates and oils as photosynthetic storage products. Diatoms lack flagella except in male gametes.
Architectural magnificence on a microscopic scale is the hallmark of the diatoms. Almost all diatoms deposit silica (hydrated silicon dioxide) in their cell walls. The cell wall of a diatom is constructed in two pieces, with the top overlapping the bottom like the top of a petri dish. The silica-impregnated walls have intricate patterns unique to each species (Figure 25.8). Despite their remarkable morphological diversity, all diatoms are symmetrical—either bilaterally (with “right” and “left” halves) or radially (with the type of symmetry possessed by a circle).
Figure 25.7 The Role of Vacuoles in Ciliate Digestion
Diatoms reproduce both sexually and asexually. Asexual reproduction by binary fission is somewhat constrained by the stiff cell wall. Both the top and bottom of the “petri dish” become tops of new “dishes” without changing appreciably in size. As a result, the new cell made from the former bottom is smaller than the parent cell. If this process continued indefinitely, one cell line would simply vanish, but sexual reproduction largely solves this potential problem. Gametes are formed, shed their cell walls, and
Figure 25.8 Diatom Diversity This bright-field micrograph illustrates the variety of species-specific forms found among the diatoms.
Media Clip 25.2 Diatoms in Action Life12e.com/mc25.2 fuse. The resulting zygote then grows substantially in size before a new cell wall is laid down.
Diatoms are found in all the oceans and are frequently present in great numbers. They are major photosynthetic producers in coastal waters (see Key Concept 25.4) and are among the dominant organisms in the dense “blooms” of phytoplankton that occasionally appear in the open ocean. Diatoms are also common in fresh water and even occur on the wet surfaces of terrestrial mosses.
BROWN ALGAE The brown algae obtain their namesake color from the carotenoid fucoxanthin, which is abundant in their chloroplasts. The combination of this yellow-orange pigment with the green of chlorophylls a and c yields a brownish tinge. All brown algae are multicellular, and some are extremely large. Giant kelps such as those of the genus Macrocystis may be up to 60 meters long.
Media Clip 25.3 A Kelp Forest Life12e.com/mc25.3
The brown algae are almost exclusively marine. They are composed either of branched filaments (Figure 25.9A) or of leaflike growths (Figure 25.9B). Some float in the open ocean; the most famous example is the genus Sargassum, which forms dense mats in the Sargasso Sea in the mid-Atlantic. Most brown algae, however, attach themselves to rocks near the shore. A few thrive only where they are regularly exposed to heavy surf. All of the attached forms develop a specialized structure, called a holdfast, that literally glues them to the rocks. The “glue” of the holdfast is alginic acid, a gummy polymer found in the walls of many brown algal cells. In addition to its function in holdfasts, alginic acid cements algal cells and filaments together. It is harvested and used by humans as an emulsifier in ice cream, cosmetics, and other products.
Figure 25.9 Brown Algae (A) This seaweed illustrates the filamentous growth form of the brown algae. (B) Sea palms exemplify the leaflike growth form of brown algae. Sea palms and many other brown algal species are “glued” to the rocks by tough, branched structures called holdfasts that can withstand the pounding of the surf.
OOMYCETES The oomycetes are the water molds and their terrestrial relatives. Water molds are filamentous and stationary. They are absorptive heterotrophs—that is, they secrete enzymes that digest large food molecules into smaller molecules that they can absorb. They are all aquatic and saprobic—meaning they feed on dead organic matter. If you have seen a whitish, cottony mold growing on dead fishes or dead insects in water, it was probably a water mold of the common genus Saprolegnia (Figure 25.10).
Figure 25.10 An Oomycete The filaments of a water mold radiate from the carcass of a beetle.
Some other oomycetes, such as the downy mildews, are terrestrial. Although most of the terrestrial oomycetes are harmless or helpful decomposers of dead matter, a few are plant parasites that attack crops such as avocados, grapes, and potatoes.
Oomycetes were once classified as fungi. However, we now know that their similarity to fungi is only superficial, and that the oomycetes are more distantly related to the fungi than are many other eukaryotic groups, including humans (see Figure 25.3). For example, the cell walls of oomycetes are typically made of cellulose, whereas those of fungi are made of chitin.
Rhizarians typically have long, thin pseudopods
The three primary groups of rhizarians—cercozoans, foraminiferans, and radiolarians—are unicellular and mostly aquatic. The rhizarians have contributed their shells to ocean sediments, some of which have become terrestrial features over the course of geological history.
CERCOZOANS The cercozoans are a diverse group with many forms and habitats. Some are aquatic; others live in soil. One group of cercozoans possesses chloroplasts derived from a green alga by secondary endosymbiosis, and those chloroplasts contain a trace of the alga’s nucleus.
FORAMINIFERANS Some foraminiferans secrete external shells of calcium carbonate (Figure 25.11). These shells have accumulated over time to produce much of the world’s limestone. Some foraminiferans live as plankton; others live on the seafloor. Living foraminiferans have been found 10,896 meters down in the western Pacific’s Challenger Deep—the deepest point in the world’s oceans. At that depth, however, they cannot secrete normal shells because the surrounding water is too poor in calcium carbonate.
Figure 25.11 Building Blocks of Limestone Some foraminiferans secrete calcium carbonate to form shells. The shells of different species have distinctive shapes. Over millions of years, the shells of foraminiferans have accumulated to form limestone deposits.
Figure 25.12 Radiolarians Exhibit Distinctive Pseudopods and Radial Symmetry (A) The radiolarians are distinguished by their thin, stiff pseudopods and by their radial symmetry. The pigmentation seen at the center of this radiolarian’s glassy endoskeleton is imparted by endosymbiotic dinoflagellates. (B) The endoskeleton secreted by a radiolarian.
In living planktonic foraminiferans, long, threadlike, branched pseudopods extend through numerous microscopic apertures in the shell and interconnect to create a sticky, reticulated net, which the foraminiferans use to catch smaller plankton. In some foraminiferan species, the pseudopods provide locomotion.
RADIOLARIANS Radiolarians are recognizable by their thin, stiff pseudopods, which are reinforced by microtubules (Figure 25.12A). These pseudopods greatly increase the surface area of the cell, and they help the cell stay afloat in its marine environment.
Radiolarians also are immediately recognizable by their distinctive radial symmetry. Almost all radiolarian species secrete glassy endoskeletons (internal skeletons). The skeletons of the different species are as varied as snowflakes, and many have elaborate geometric designs (Figure 25.12B). A few radiolarians are among the largest of the unicellular eukaryotes, measuring several millimeters across.
Excavates began to diversify about 1.5 billion years ago
The excavates include several diverse groups that began to split from one another soon after the origin of eukaryotes. Several groups of excavates lack mitochondria, an absence that once led to the view that these groups might represent early-diverging eukaryotes that diversified before the evolution of mitochondria. However, the discovery of genes in the nucleus that are normally associated with mitochondria suggests that the absence of mitochondria is a derived condition in these organisms. In other words, ancestors of these excavate groups probably possessed mitochondria that were lost or reduced over the course of evolution. The existence of these organisms today shows that eukaryotic life is possible without mitochondria, at least among parasitic species.
DIPLOMONADS AND PARABASALIDS The diplomonads and the parabasalids are unicellular and lack mitochondria (although they have reduced organelles that are derived from mitochondria). The parasitic Giardia lamblia, a diplomonad, causes the intestinal disease giardiasis. Giardia infections may result from contact with contaminated water. In the United States, such infections are common among hikers and campers using spring or stream water in recreational areas, as well as among children kept in close quarters (as in day-care centers). The tiny Giardia contain two nuclei bounded by nuclear envelopes and have a cytoskeleton and multiple flagella (Figure 25.13A).
In addition to flagella and a cytoskeleton, the parabasalids have undulating membranes that also contribute to the cell’s locomotion. Trichomonas vaginalis (Figure 25.13B) is a parabasalid responsible for a sexually transmitted disease in humans. Infection of the male urethra, where it may occur without symptoms, is less common than infection of the vagina.
Figure 25.13 Some Excavate Groups Lack Mitochondria (A) Giardia, a diplomonad, has flagella and two nuclei. (B) Trichomonas, a parabasalid, has flagella and undulating membranes. Neither of these organisms possess mitochondria.
Figure 25.14 A Photosynthetic Euglenid In the Euglena species illustrated in this drawing, the second flagellum is rudimentary. Note that the primary flagellum originates at the anterior of the organism and trails toward its posterior.
HETEROLOBOSEANS The amoeboid body form appears in several protist groups that are only distantly related to one another. The body forms of heteroloboseans, for example, resemble those of loboseans, an amoebozoan group that is not at all closely related to heteroloboseans (see the next section). Amoebas of the free-living heterolobosean genus Naegleria, some of which can enter the human body and cause a fatal disease of the nervous system, usually have a two-stage life cycle, in which one stage has amoeboid cells and the other flagellated cells.
EUGLENIDS AND KINETOPLASTIDS The euglenids and kinetoplastids together constitute a clade of unicellular excavates with flagella. Their mitochondria contain distinctive disc-shaped cristae, and their flagella contain a crystalline rod not found in other organisms. They reproduce primarily asexually by binary fission.
The flagella of euglenids arise from a pocket at the anterior end of the cell. Spiraling strips of proteins under the cell membrane control the cell’s shape. Some euglenids are photosynthetic. Figure 25.14 depicts a typical cell of the genus Euglena. Like most other euglenids, this common freshwater organism has a complex cell structure. It propels itself through the water with the longer of its two flagella, which may also serve as an anchor to hold the organism in place. The second flagellum is often rudimentary.
The euglenids have diverse nutritional requirements. Many species are always heterotrophic. Other species, including species of Euglena, are fully autotrophic in sunlight, using chloroplasts to synthesize organic compounds through photosynthesis. When kept in the dark, these euglenids lose their photosynthetic pigment and begin to feed exclusively on dissolved organic material in the water around them. A “bleached” Euglena resynthesizes its photosynthetic pigment when it is returned to the light and becomes autotrophic again. But Euglena cells treated with certain antibiotics or mutagens lose their photosynthetic pigment completely; neither they nor their descendants are ever autotrophs again. However, those descendants function well as heterotrophs.
The kinetoplastids are unicellular parasites with two flagella and a single, large mitochondrion. The mitochondrion contains a kinetoplast, a unique structure housing multiple circular DNA molecules and associated proteins. Some of these DNA molecules encode “guide proteins” that edit mRNA within the mitochondrion.
The kinetoplastids include several medically important species of pathogenic trypanosomes (Table 25.1). Some of these organisms are able to change their cell surface recognition molecules frequently, allowing them to evade our best attempts to kill them and thus eradicate the diseases they cause.
Amoebozoans use lobe-shaped pseudopods for locomotion
Amoebozoans appear to have diverged from other eukaryotes about 1.5 billion years ago (see Figure 25.3). It is not yet clear whether they are more closely related to opisthokonts (which include fungi and animals) or to other major groups of eukaryotes.
The lobe-shaped pseudopods of amoebozoans (Figure 25.15) are a hallmark of the amoeboid body form. Amoebozoan pseudopods differ in form and function from the slender pseudopods of rhizarians. We consider three amoebozoan groups here: the loboseans and two groups known as slime molds.
LOBOSEANS Loboseans are small amoebozoans that feed on other small organisms and particles of organic matter by phagocytosis, engulfing them with pseudopods. Many loboseans are adapted for life on the bottoms of lakes, ponds, and other bodies of water. Their creeping locomotion and their manner of engulfing food particles fit them for life close to a relatively rich supply of sedentary organisms or organic particles. Most loboseans exist as predators, parasites, or scavengers. Members of one group of loboseans, the testate amoebas, live inside shells. Some of
Table 25.1 Three Pathogenic Trypanosomes
| Trypanosoma brucei | Trypanosoma cruzi | Leishmania major | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Human disease | Sleeping sickness | Chagas disease | Leishmaniasis |
| Insect vector | Tsetse fly | Assassin bugs (many species) | Sand fly |
| Vaccine or effective cure | None | None | None |
| Strategy for survival | Changes surface recognition molecules frequently | Causes changes in surface recognition molecules on host cell | Reduces effectiveness of macrophage hosts |
| Site in human body | Bloodstream; in final stages, attacks nerve tissue | Enters cells, especially muscle cells | Enters cells, primarily macrophages |
| Approximate number of deaths per year | 7,000 | 11,000 | 63,000 |
Figure 25.15 An Amoeba in Motion The flowing pseudopods of this “chaos amoeba” (a lobosean) are constantly changing shape as the amoeba moves and feeds.
Figure 25.16 Life in a Glass House This testate amoeba has built a lightbulb-shaped shell, or test, by gluing sand grains together. Its pseudopods extend through the single aperture in the test.
these amoebas produce casings by gluing sand grains together (Figure 25.16). Other testate amoebas have shells secreted by the organism itself.
PLASMODIAL SLIME MOLDS If the nucleus of an amoeba began rapid mitotic division, accompanied by a tremendous increase in cytoplasm and organelles but no cytokinesis, the resulting organism would resemble the multinucleate mass of a plasmodial slime mold. During its vegetative (feeding, nonreproductive) stage, a plasmodial slime mold is a wall-less mass of cytoplasm with numerous diploid nuclei. This mass streams very slowly over its substrate in a remarkable network of strands called a plasmodium (Figure 25.17A). The plasmodium is an example of a coenocyte: many nuclei enclosed in a single cell membrane. The outer cytoplasm of the plasmodium (closest to the environment) is normally less fluid than the interior cytoplasm and thus provides some structural rigidity.
Plasmodial slime molds provide a dramatic example of movement by cytoplasmic streaming. The outer cytoplasm of the plasmodium becomes more fluid in places, and cytoplasm rushes into those areas, stretching the plasmodium. This streaming reverses its direction every few minutes as cytoplasm rushes into a new area and drains away from a previous one, moving the plasmodium over its substrate. Sometimes an entire wave of plasmodium moves across a surface, leaving strands behind. Microfilaments and a contractile protein called myxomyosin interact to produce the streaming movement. As it moves, the plasmodium engulfs food particles by endocytosis—predominantly bacteria, yeasts, spores of fungi, and other small organisms as well as decaying animal and plant remains.
A plasmodial slime mold can grow almost indefinitely in its plasmodial stage as long as the food supply is adequate and other conditions, such as moisture and pH, are favorable. If conditions become unfavorable, however, one of two things can happen. First, the plasmodium can form an irregular mass of hardened cell-like components. This resting structure rapidly becomes a plasmodium again when favorable conditions are restored.
Alternatively, the plasmodium can transform itself into spore-bearing fruiting structures (Figure 25.17B). These stalked or branched structures rise from heaped masses of plasmodium. They derive their rigidity from walls that form and thicken between their nuclei. The diploid nuclei of the plasmodium divide by meiosis as the fruiting structure develops. One or more knobs, called sporangia, develop on the end of the stalk. Within a sporangium, haploid nuclei become surrounded by walls to form spores. Eventually, as the fruiting structure dries, it sheds its spores.
The spores germinate into wall-less, haploid cells called swarm cells, which can either divide mitotically to produce more haploid swarm cells or function as gametes. Swarm cells can live as separate individual cells that move by means of flagella or pseudopods, or they can become walled and resistant resting cysts when conditions are unfavorable; when conditions improve again, the cysts release swarm cells. Two swarm cells can also fuse to form a diploid zygote, which divides by mitosis (but without a wall forming between the nuclei) and thus forms a new coenocytic plasmodium.
Figure 25.17 A Plasmodial Slime Mold (A) The plasmodial form of the slime mold Hemitrichia serpula covers rocks, decaying logs, and other objects as it engulfs bacteria and other food items; it is also responsible for the organism’s common name of “pretzel mold.” (B) Fruiting structures of Leocarpus fragilis.
CELLULAR SLIME MOLDS Whereas the plasmodium is the basic vegetative unit of the plasmodial slime molds, a single amoeboid cell is the vegetative unit of the cellular slime molds (Figure 25.18). Cells called myxamoebas, which have single haploid nuclei, swarm together as they engulf bacteria and other food particles by endocytosis and reproduce by mitosis and fission. This simple life cycle stage, consisting of swarms of independent, isolated cells, can persist indefinitely as long as food and moisture are available.
Figure 25.18 A Cellular Slime Mold This composite micrograph shows the life cycle of a Dictyostelium slime mold.
When conditions become unfavorable, the cellular slime molds form fruiting structures, as do their plasmodial counterparts. The individual myxamoebas aggregate into a mass called a slug or pseudoplasmodium. Unlike the true plasmodium of the plasmodial slime molds, this structure is not simply a giant sheet of cytoplasm with many nuclei; the individual myxamoebas within the slug retain their cell membranes and therefore their identity.
A slug may migrate over a substrate for several hours before becoming motionless and reorganizing to construct a delicate, stalked fruiting structure. Cells at the top of the fruiting structure develop into thick-walled spores, which are eventually released. Later, under favorable conditions, the spores germinate, releasing myxamoebas.
The cycle from myxamoebas through slug and spores to new myxamoebas is asexual. Cellular slime molds also have a sexual cycle, in which two myxamoebas fuse. The product of this fusion develops into a spherical structure that ultimately germinates, releasing new haploid myxamoebas.
Recap and Assess
The major lineages of eukaryotes began to diverge about 1.5 billion years ago. Major groups of eukaryotes are highly diverse in their habitat, nutrition, locomotion, and body form. Many protists are photosynthetic autotrophs, but heterotrophic lineages have evolved repeatedly. Although most protists are unicellular, multicellularity has arisen independently many times.
- For each pair of groups below, describe how you could recognize
members of the two groups and differentiate them from one another. Then
describe features that the two groups in each pair share.
- Foraminiferans and radiolarians
- Ciliates and dinoflagellates
- Diatoms and brown algae
- Plasmodial slime molds and cellular slime molds
- The fossil record of eukaryotes from the Precambrian is poor compared with that from the Cambrian and later geological periods, even though eukaryotes were diversifying for the last billion years of the Precambrian. Can you think of some reasons why the eukaryotic fossil record became more extensive in the Cambrian?
- Give examples of alveolates, stramenopiles, and excavates that are important for medical or culinary reasons.
- The red tides produced by some dinoflagellates are not produced by other alveolates. But similar red tides are produced by some diatoms, which are distantly related to dinoflagellates. Thus the production of red tides is convergent in dinoflagellates and diatoms. Describe another example from the text of convergent evolution in protists but outside alveolates.
The ancient origins of the major eukaryotic lineages and the adaptation of these lineages to a wide variety of lifestyles and environments resulted in enormous protist diversity. It is not surprising, then, that reproductive modes among protists are also highly diverse.
Protists Reproduce Sexually and Asexually
Learning Objectives
25.3.1 Distinguish between sex (in the sense of exchange of genes leading to genetic recombination) and reproduction.
25.3.2 Predict the evolutionary consequences of reproduction without sex for many generations.
Although most protists engage in both asexual and sexual reproduction, sexual reproduction has yet to be observed in some groups. In some protists, as in all prokaryotes, the acts of sex and reproduction are not directly linked.
Several asexual reproductive processes have been observed among the protists:
- The equal splitting of one cell into two by mitosis followed by cytokinesis
- The splitting of one cell into multiple (i.e., more than two) cells
- The outgrowth of a new cell from the surface of an old one (known as budding)
- The formation of specialized cells (spores) that are capable of developing into new individuals (known as sporulation)
Asexual reproduction results in offspring that are genetically nearly identical to their parents (they differ only by new mutations that may arise during DNA replication). Such asexually reproduced groups of nearly identical organisms are known as clonal lineages.
Sexual reproduction among the protists takes various forms. In some protists, as in animals, the gametes are the only haploid cells. In others, the zygote is the only diploid cell. In still others, both diploid and haploid cells undergo mitosis, giving rise to alternating multicellular diploid and haploid life stages.
Some protists reproduce without sex and have sex without reproduction
As we noted in Key Concept 25.2, members of the genus Paramecium are ciliates, which commonly have two types of nuclei in a single cell (one macronucleus and from one to several micronuclei; see Figure 25.6). The micronuclei are typical eukaryotic nuclei and are essential for genetic recombination. Each macronucleus contains many copies of the genetic information, packaged in units containing only a few genes each. The macronuclear DNA is transcribed and translated to regulate the life of the cell.
When paramecia reproduce asexually, all of the nuclei are copied before the cell divides. Paramecia (and many other protists) also have an elaborate sexual behavior called conjugation, in which two individuals line up tightly against each other and fuse in the oral groove region of the body. Nuclear material is extensively reorganized and exchanged over the next several hours (Figure 25.19). Each cell ends up with two haploid micronuclei, one of its own and one from the other cell, which fuse to form a new diploid micronucleus. A new macronucleus develops from that micronucleus through a series of dramatic chromosomal rearrangements. The exchange of nuclei is fully reciprocal: each of the two paramecia gives and receives an equal amount of DNA. The two organisms then separate and go their own ways, each equipped with new combinations of alleles.
Conjugation in Paramecium is a sexual process of genetic recombination, but it is not a reproductive process. Two cells begin
Figure 25.19 Conjugation in Paramecia The exchange of micronuclei by two conjugating Paramecium individuals results in genetic recombination. After conjugation, the cells separate and continue their lives as two individuals.
Q: Why is conjugation considered sex without reproduction?
conjugation and two cells are there at the end, so no new cells are created. As a rule, each asexual clone of paramecia must conjugate periodically. Experiments have shown that if some species are not permitted to conjugate, the clones can live through only about 350 cell divisions before dying out.
Some protist life cycles feature alternation of generations
Alternation of generations is a type of life cycle found in many multicellular protists, all land plants, and some fungi (see Figure 26.6). A multicellular, diploid, spore-producing organism gives rise to a multicellular, haploid, gamete-producing organism. When two haploid gametes fuse, a diploid organism is produced. The haploid organism, the diploid organism, or both may also reproduce asexually. Note that alternation of generations is distinct from the familiar reproductive system of animals, in which the only haploid stages are unicellular gametes produced by multicellular, diploid adults.
The two alternating (spore-producing and gamete-producing) generations differ genetically (one has diploid cells, the other haploid cells), but they may or may not differ morphologically. In heteromorphic alternation of generations, the two generations differ morphologically; in isomorphic alternation of generations, they do not. Examples of both heteromorphic and isomorphic alternation of generations are found among the brown algae.
The gamete-producing generation does not produce gametes by meiosis because the gamete-producing organism is already haploid. Instead, specialized cells of the diploid spore-producing organism, called sporocytes, divide meiotically to produce four haploid spores. The spores may eventually germinate and divide meiotically to produce the multicellular haploid generation, which then produces gametes by mitosis and cytokinesis.
Gametes, unlike spores, can produce new organisms only by fusing with other gametes. The fusion of two gametes produces a diploid zygote, which then undergoes mitotic divisions to produce a diploid organism. The diploid organism’s sporocytes then undergo meiosis and produce haploid spores, starting the cycle anew.
Recap and Assess
Protists reproduce both asexually and sexually, although sex occurs independently of reproduction in some species. Some multicellular protists exhibit alternation of generations, alternating between multicellular haploid and diploid life stages.
- Why is conjugation between paramecia considered a sexual process but not a reproductive process?
- Why do you think paramecia that are not allowed to conjugate begin to die out after about 350 rounds of asexual reproduction?
- Although most diploid animals have haploid stages (e.g., eggs and sperm), their life cycles are not considered examples of alternation of generations. Why not?
Given the diversity of protists and of the environments in which they live, it is not surprising that they influence their environments in numerous ways.
Protists Are Critical Components of Many Ecosystems
Learning Objectives
- 25.4.1 Illustrate and/or describe the complex life cycle of a parasite that involves multiple hosts.
- 25.4.2 Summarize the consequences of overproduction of some diatoms and dinoflagellates.
- 25.4.3 Describe some of the beneficial and harmful interactions that protists have with other species.
- 25.4.4 Provide two examples of how protists are important to humans.
Some protists are food for marine animals, while others poison those animals. Some are packaged as nutritional supplements for humans, and some are human pathogens. The remains of some form the sands of many modern beaches, and others are a major source of the oil that sometimes fouls those beaches.
Phytoplankton are primary producers
A single protist clade, the diatoms, performs about one-fifth of all photosynthetic carbon fixation on Earth—about the same amount as all of Earth’s rainforests. These spectacular unicellular organisms (see Figure 25.8) are the predominant component of the oceanic phytoplankton, but the phytoplankton include many other protists that also contribute heavily to global photosynthesis. Like green plants on land, these “floating photosynthesizers” are the gateway for energy from the Sun into the rest of the living world; in other words, they are primary producers. These autotrophs are eaten by heterotrophs, including animals and many other protists. Those consumers are, in turn, eaten by other consumers. Most aquatic heterotrophs (with the exception of some species in the deep sea) depend on photosynthesis performed by phytoplankton.
Some microbial eukaryotes are deadly
Some microbial eukaryotes are pathogens that cause serious diseases in humans and other vertebrates. The best-known pathogenic protists are members of the genus Plasmodium, a highly specialized group of apicomplexans that spend part of their life cycle as parasites in human red blood cells, where they are the cause of malaria. In terms of the number of people affected, malaria is one of the world’s three most serious infectious diseases: it infects more than 215 million people, and kills nearly half a million people, each year. On average, about two people die from malaria every minute of every day—most of them in sub-Saharan Africa, although malaria occurs in more than 90 countries.
Mosquitoes of the genus Anopheles transmit Plasmodium to humans. The parasites enter the human circulatory system when an infected female Anopheles mosquito penetrates the skin in search of blood. The parasites find their way to cells in the liver and the lymphatic system, change their form, multiply, and reenter the bloodstream, where they invade red blood cells.
The parasites multiply inside the red blood cells, which then lyse (burst), releasing new swarms of parasites. These episodes of bursting red blood cells coincide with the primary symptoms of malaria, which include fever, shivering, vomiting, joint pains, and convulsions. If another Anopheles bites the victim, the mosquito takes in Plasmodium cells along with blood. Some of the ingested cells develop into gametes that unite in the mosquito, forming zygotes. The zygotes lodge in the mosquito’s gut, divide several times, and move into its salivary glands, from which they can be passed on to another human host. Thus Plasmodium is an extracellular parasite in the mosquito vector and an intracellular parasite in the human host (Figure 25.20). Such an organism—that is, a parasite that requires more than one host—is said to have a complex life cycle.
Plasmodium has proved to be a singularly difficult pathogen to attack. The complex Plasmodium life cycle is best broken by the removal of stagnant water, in which mosquitoes breed. Using insecticides to reduce the Anopheles population can also be effective, but the benefits must be weighed against the ecological, economic, and health risks posed by the insecticides themselves.
Figure 25.20 Life Cycle of the Malarial Parasite (A) Like many parasitic species, the apicomplexan Plasmodium falciparum has a complex life cycle, part of which is spent in mosquitoes of the genus Anopheles and part in humans. The sexual phase (gamete fusion) of this life cycle takes place in the insect, and the zygote is the only diploid stage. (B) Encysted Plasmodium zygotes (artificially colored blue) cover the stomach wall of a mosquito. Invasive sporozoites will hatch from the cysts and be transmitted to a human, in whom the parasite causes malaria.
Even some of the phytoplankton that are such important primary producers can be deadly, as described in this chapter’s opening story. Some diatoms and dinoflagellates reproduce in enormous numbers when environmental conditions are favorable for their growth. In the resulting red tides, the concentration of dinoflagellates may reach 60 million per liter of ocean water and produce potent nerve toxins that harm or kill many vertebrates, especially fishes.
Some microbial eukaryotes are endosymbionts
Endosymbiosis is common among the microbial eukaryotes, many of which live within the cells of animals. Many radiolarians harbor photosynthetic endosymbionts (see Figure 25.12A). As a result, these radiolarians, which are not photosynthetic themselves, appear greenish or golden, depending on the type of endosymbiont they contain. This arrangement is often mutually beneficial: the radiolarian can make use of the carbon compounds produced by its photosynthetic guest, and the guest may in turn make use of metabolites made by the host or receive physical protection. In some cases, the guest is exploited for its photosynthetic products while receiving little or no benefit itself.
Dinoflagellates are also common endosymbionts and can be found in both animals and other protists. Most, but not all, dinoflagellate endosymbionts are photosynthetic. Some dinoflagellates live endosymbiotically in the cells of corals, contributing the products of their photosynthesis to the partnership. Their importance to the corals is demonstrated when the dinoflagellates die or are expelled by the corals as a result of changing environmental conditions such as rising water temperatures or increased water turbidity. This phenomenon is known as coral bleaching. Unless the corals can acquire new endosymbionts, they are ultimately damaged or destroyed as a result of their reduced food supply (Investigating Life: Can Corals Reacquire Dinoflagellate Endosymbionts Lost to Bleaching?).
Investigating Life: Can Corals Reacquire Dinoflagellate Endosymbionts Lost to Bleaching?
Experiment
Original Paper: C. L. Lewis and M. A. Coffroth. 2004. The acquisition of exogenous algal symbionts by an octocoral after bleaching. Science 304: 1490–1492.
Some corals lose their chief nutritional source when their photosynthetic endosymbionts die, often as a result of changing environmental conditions. This experiment by Cynthia Lewis and Mary Alice Coffroth investigated the ability of corals to acquire new endosymbionts after bleaching.
HYPOTHESIS Bleached corals can acquire new photo-synthetic endosymbionts from their environment.
METHOD
- Count numbers of Symbiodinium, a photosynthetic dinoflagellate, living symbiotically in samples of a coral (Briareum sp.).
- Stimulate bleaching by maintaining all Briareum colonies in darkness for 12 weeks.
- After 12 weeks of darkness, count numbers of Symbiodinium in the coral samples; then return all colonies to light.
- In some of the bleached colonies (the experimental group), introduce Symbiodinium strain B211—dinoflagellates that contain a unique molecular marker. Do not expose the others (the control group) to strain B211. Maintain both groups in the light for 6 weeks.
RESULTS Error bars show 95% confidence limits for the means.
Pre-bleach
Post-bleach
Both photos courtesy of M. A. Coffroth and C. Lewis, University at Barifao
CONCLUSION Corals can acquire new endosymbionts from their environment following bleaching.
We rely on the remains of ancient marine protists
Diatoms are lovely to look at, but their importance to us goes far beyond aesthetics, and even beyond their role as primary producers. Diatoms store oil as an energy reserve and to keep themselves afloat at the correct depth in the ocean. Over millions of years, diatoms have died and sunk to the ocean floor, where they have undergone chemical changes. In this way, they have become a major source of petroleum and natural gas, two of our most important energy supplies and political concerns.
Because the silica-containing cell walls of dead diatoms resist decomposition, some sedimentary rocks are composed almost entirely of diatom skeletons that sank to the seafloor over time. Diatomaceous earth, which is obtained from such rocks, has many industrial uses, such as insulation, filtration, and metal polishing. It has also been used as an “Earth-friendly” insecticide that clogs the tracheae (breathing structures) of insects.
Other ancient marine protists have also contributed to today’s world. Some foraminiferans, as we have seen, secrete shells of calcium carbonate. After they reproduce (by mitosis and cytokinesis), the daughter cells abandon the parent shell and make new shells of their own. The discarded shells of ancient foraminiferans make up extensive limestone deposits in various parts of the world, forming a layer hundreds to thousands of meters deep over millions of square kilometers of ocean bottom. Foraminiferan shells also make up much of the sand of some beaches. A single gram of such sand may contain as many as 50,000 foraminiferan shells and shell fragments.
The shells of individual foraminiferans are easily preserved as fossils in marine sediments. Each geological period has a distinctive assemblage of foraminiferan species. Because the shells of foraminiferan species have distinctive shapes (see Figure 25.11) and because they are so abundant, the remains of foraminiferans are especially valuable in classifying and dating sedimentary rocks. In addition, analyses of the chemical makeup of foraminiferan shells can be used to estimate the global temperatures prevalent at the time when the shells were formed.
Work with the Data
The data in the table below come from DNA analyses of Symbiodinium strains found in the experimental and control colonies of corals (Briareum) before and after bleaching. Symbiodinium strain B211 (which was not present before bleaching) was introduced to the experimental colonies after bleaching. Use these data to answer the questions below.
| Symbiodinium strain present (% of colonies) | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Non-B211 | B211 | None a | Colony died | |
| EXPERIMENTAL COLONIES (STRAIN B211 ADDED) | ||||
| Pre-bleach | 100 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Post-bleach | 58 | 0 | 42 | 0 |
| Week 3 | 0 | 92 | 0 | 8 |
| Week 6 | 8 | 58 | 8 | 25 |
| CONTROL COLONIES (NO STRAIN B211) | ||||
| Pre-bleach | 100 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| Post-bleach | 67 | 0 | 33 | 0 |
| Week 3 | 67 | 0 | 33 | 0 |
| Week 6 | 67 | 0 | 17 | 17 |
aColonies remained alive, but no Symbiodinium were detected.
QUESTIONS►
- Are new strains of Symbiodinium taken up only by coral colonies that have lost all their original endosymbionts?
- Does the acquisition of a new Symbiodinium strain always result in survival of a recovering Briareum colony?
- In week 3, only strain B211 was detected in the experimental colonies, but in week 6, non-B211 Symbiodinium were detected in 8% of the experimental colonies. Can you suggest an explanation for this observation?
Recap and Assess
Protists have many effects, both positive and negative, on their environment. Some species are important primary producers, many are endosymbionts, and some are pathogens. Protists are among the most important producers of fossil fuels, and they are important components of sedimentary rocks.
- What is the role of female Anopheles mosquitoes in the transmission of malaria?
- Explain the roles of dinoflagellates in the two very different phenomena of coral bleaching and red tides.
- What are two ways in which diatoms are important to human society?
The next six chapters will explore the major evolutionary radiations of multicellular eukaryotes, along with the protist ancestors from which they arose. Chapters 26 and 27 will describe the origin and diversification of plants, Chapter 28 will present the fungi, and Chapters 29–31 will provide a brief overview of the animals.
Investigating Life
Q&A Red tides are harmful, but how are dinoflagellates beneficial to marine ecosystems?
The opening of this chapter discussed harmful red tides, or blooms of dinoflagellates. But not all dinoflagellate blooms produce problems for other species. Dinoflagellates are important components of many ecosystems, as we have seen throughout this chapter. Photosynthetic dinoflagellates also produce much of the atmospheric oxygen that most animals need to survive.
As we saw in Investigating Life: Can Corals Reacquire Dinoflagellate Endosymbionts Lost to Bleaching?, corals and many other species depend on symbiotic dinoflagellates for food. In addition, as photosynthetic organisms, free-living planktonic dinoflagellates are among the most important primary producers in aquatic food webs. They are a major component of the phytoplankton and provide an important food source for many species.
Future directions
Some dinoflagellates produce a beautiful bioluminescence (Figure 25.21). Unlike the bioluminescent bacteria described at the start of Chapter 24, however, dinoflagellates cannot generate a steady bioluminescence, but instead produce bright flashes of light when disturbed, as people who swim in the ocean at night in certain regions often observe. What function do these flashes serve? Many light-emitting dinoflagellates are preyed on by other species, such as small crustaceans. When the dinoflagellates produce a bright flash, it functions like a “burglar alarm,” and attracts secondary predators of the crustaceans. Experiments have shown that crustaceans reduce their feeding on dinoflagellates when they flash this signal. However, recent research shows another function of bioluminescence in toxic species of dinoflagellates. These toxic species produce a much lower intensity bioluminescence which may function as a warning of their toxicity to potential predators. So depending on the intensity and other details of the flash in different species, the bioluminescence can serve either to attract secondary predators or to warn off primary predators. Research on communication by bioluminescence continues as a rich field of investigation.
Figure 25.21 Light Up the Sea Bioluminescent dinoflagellates flash as an outrigger disturbs the ocean surface off the island of Bali.
© Don Paulson/PureStock/AGE Fotostock
Visual Summary
You should be able to relate each summary to the adjacent figures. If you go to this visual summary in Achieve, you can follow links to figures, animations, activities, and simulations that will help you consolidate the material.
Eukaryotes Acquired Features from Both Archaea and Bacteria
- ■ The term protist does not describe a formal taxonomic group. It is shorthand for “all eukaryotes that are not plants, animals, or fungi.”
- ■ Early events in the evolution of the eukaryotic cell included the loss of the firm cell wall and infolding of the cell membrane. Such infolding led to segregation of the genetic material in a membrane-enclosed nucleus.
- ■ Mitochondria evolved by endosymbiosis with a proteobacterium.
- ■ Primary endosymbiosis of a eukaryote and a cyanobacterium gave rise to the first chloroplasts.
- ■ Secondary endosymbiosis and tertiary endosymbiosis between chloroplast-containing eukaryotes and other eukaryotes gave rise to the distinctive chloroplasts of euglenids, dinoflagellates, and other groups.
Questions
- Are all protists small in size (microbial)?
- What is the phylogenetic evidence that mitochondria and chloroplasts arose through endosymbiosis?
Figure 25.1
Figure 25.2
Major Lineages of Eukaryotes Diversified in the Precambrian
Most eukaryotes can be placed in one of eight major clades that diverged about 1.5 billion years ago: alveolates, stramenopiles, rhizarians, excavates, plants, amoebozoans, fungi, and animals.
Alveolates are unicellular organisms with sacs (alveoli) beneath their cell membranes. Alveolate clades include the marine dinoflagellates, the parasitic apicomplexans, and the diverse, highly motile ciliates.
Stramenopiles typically have two flagella of unequal length, the longer one bearing rows of tubular hairs. Among the stramenopiles are the unicellular diatoms; the multicellular brown algae; and the nonphotosynthetic oomycetes, many of which are saprobic.
Rhizarians are unicellular and aquatic. They include the cercozoans; the foraminiferans, which secrete shells of calcium carbonate; and the radiolarians, which have thin, stiff pseudopods and glassy endoskeletons.
The unicellular excavates include parasitic as well as free-living species, some of which have lost typical mitochondria.
The amoebozoans move by means of lobe-shaped pseudopods and include both unicellular and multicellular members; examples are the plasmodial slime molds and cellular slime molds.
Questions
- Name five of the major groups of eukaryotes in which multicellularity has arisen independently.
- Which five of the major groups of eukaryotes contain numerous photosynthetic species?
Figure 25.3
Protists Reproduce Sexually and Asexually
- ■ Asexual reproduction gives rise to clonal lineages of organisms.
- ■ Conjugation in Paramecium is a sexual process but not a reproductive one.
- ■ Alternation of generations, which involves cycles between a multicellular diploid stage and a multicellular haploid stage, is a feature of many multicellular protist life cycles (as well as those of some fungi and all land plants).
The alternating generations may be heteromorphic or isomorphic.
Questions
- Explain how some species can recombine their genomes sexually, yet reproduce asexually.
- Why is animal reproduction, which involves haploid gametes produced by diploid organisms, not considered alternation of generations?
Figure 25.19
Protists Are Critical Components of Many Ecosystems
- ■ Diatoms are responsible for about one-fifth of the photosynthetic carbon fixation on Earth. They and other members of the phytoplankton are important primary producers in the marine environment. Ancient diatoms are a major source of today’s petroleum and natural gas deposits.
- ■ Some protists are pathogens of humans and other vertebrates.
- ■ Endosymbiotic relationships are common among microbial protists and often benefit both the endosymbionts and their protist or animal partners.
Questions
- Describe two distinct problems for human populations that are caused by protists.
- What are two important benefits to humans from protists?
Figure 25.20