Chapter 3Proteins and NMR Structural Biology

As mentioned in the previous chapter, one-dimensional NMR techniques, which yield extremely useful information in small molecules, are of limited applicability to the complex, highly overlapped spectra of biological macromolecules. To effectively use the information available from NMR spectroscopy of biological macromolecules, we introduced multidimensional NMR spectroscopy. It combines data from several kinds of spectra to establish the mappings for resonance assignments. In general, there are two types of multidimensional spectra, homonuclear spectra, in which each axis represents the same type of atom (usually protons), and heteronuclear spectra, in which each axis represents a different type of atom. In this lecture, we briefly introduce several essential multidimensional NMR experiments and techniques.

COSY

Homonuclear correlation spectroscopy (COSY) is two-dimensional, and shows the frequencies for a single isotope (usually protons) along both axes of the spectrum. As shown in figure 3.1, the COSY spectrum consists of a series of peaks on the diagonal, and the peaks that appear off of the diagonal are called cross-peaks. These cross-peaks are symmetrical (above and below the diagonal) and indicate which protons are spin-spin coupled with each other. Therefore, by matching the center of a cross-peak with the center of each of two corresponding diagonal peaks, one can determine which atoms are connected to one another by chemical bonds. The peaks on the diagonal and the matched cross-peaks are coupled to each other.

3JHNHα^3J_{\text{HNH}\alpha}

The three-dimensional HNHα\text{HNH}^\alpha (3JHNHα^3J_{\text{HNH}\alpha}) experiment is designed to accurately determine three-bond HN-Hα\text{H}^N\text{-H}^\alpha J-coupling constants (also called scalar couplings). While the NOE provides information on the distance between two nuclei, this J-coupling constant is dependent on the dihedral angle in the structure. In particular, this coupling constant provides information about the dihedral angles subtended by the coupled atoms. For example, we can derive the dihedral angle ϕ\phi by mapping J-coupling constants in the Karplus curve as shown in figure 3.2.

Figure 3.1 COSY spectrum of proton-proton scalar couplings.

Figure 3.2 The Karplus relationship between the three-bond coupling constant 3JHNHα^3J_{\text{HNH}\alpha} and the torsional angle ϕ\phi . The Karplus curve is calculated as 3J(ϕ)=Acos⁡2(ϕ−60)+Bcos⁡(ϕ−60)+C^3J(\phi) = A \cos^2(\phi - 60) + B \cos(\phi - 60) + C , where AA , BB , and CC are empirically derived parameters. Credit: http://www.cryst.bbk.ac.uk/PPS.

HN−15N\text{H}^{\text{N}-^{15}\text{N}} HSQC

Heteronuclear Single Quantum Correlation (HSQC) is one of the most important two-dimensional NMR experiments. It correlates the nitrogen atom of an NH moiety with the directly attached proton, and each signal in an HSQC spectrum represents a proton that is bound to a nitrogen atom. Since every residue except proline has (ideally) a unique HN−15N\text{H}^{\text{N}-^{15}\text{N}} pair on the protein backbone and ideally has distinct frequency signals, the HSQC spectrum can serve as the identification (“hash code”) of each residue, and reference interaction for all other spectra. The HSQC spectrum also contains signals from the NH groups of the side-chains, such as Asn and Gln and the aromatic HN\text{H}^{\text{N}} protons of Trp and His. Unlike homonuclear spectra, the HSQC spectrum has no diagonal because different nuclei are observed during the relaxation periods T1T_1 and T2T_2 (figure 3.3).

15N^{15}\text{N} TOCSY

3D Total Correlation Spectroscopy (TOCSY) is a three-dimensional (3D) heteronuclear NMR experiment. In contrast to the HN−15N\text{H}^{\text{N}-^{15}\text{N}} HSQC, TOCSY experiments record the side-chain protons as the third axis in the spectrum. Figure 3.4 shows a TOCSY spectrum by fixing the 15N^{15}\text{N} atoms from 3D data, in which the peaks are from side-chain protons and Hα\text{H}^\alpha , and the strips group atoms by the spin system. In this spectrum, the xx -axis is the HN\text{H}^N shift; the yy -axis shows the Hα\text{H}^\alpha and the side-chain shifts, and the zz -axis (projected out) gives the 15N^{15}\text{N} shift. Given the fact that the chemical shifts of protons for different amino acids are characteristically different, we can regard these strips (number and position of peaks) as the “fingerprints” of the protons to identify probable amino acid types.

Figure 3.3 The NMR spectrum of HN−15N\text{H}^{\text{N}-^{15}\text{N}} HSQC.

Figure 3.4 The NMR spectrum of 15N^{15}\text{N} TOCSY. Each strip indicates atoms grouped by the spin system.

Having constrained the amino acid type for each peak in HSQC from TOCSY experiments, in order to obtain actual assignments, we still need to establish the sequential connectivities between spin systems. Generally, we combine information from different NMR experiments by cross-referencing peaks to reveal the sequential connectivities, for example, HN(CO)CA and HNCA. These correlate the HN\text{H}^N , N\text{N} , and Cα\text{C}^\alpha nuclei in a residue, and in the previous residue in the protein. Note that prolines will not generate peaks in any spectrum that involves the backbone amide, for example, HSQC, NH(CO)CA, HNCA, 15N^{15}\text{N} TOCSY.

NOESY

The Nuclear Overhauser Effect (NOE) is caused by dipolar coupling between nuclei, that is, the local field at one nucleus is affected by the presence of another nucleus. The intensity of the interactions is (ideally) a function of the distance between the nuclei according to the following equation

I=A(1/r6),I = A(1/r^6), where II is the intensity that is measured, AA is a scaling constant, and rr is the distance between nuclei. In other words, NOE provides a link between an experimentally measurable quantity, II , and internuclear distance. NOEs are measured with NOE spectroscopy (NOESY) experiments. For example, 3D 15N-HSQC^{15}\text{N-HSQC} NOESY, a 3D heteronuclear NMR experiment, measures the through-space NOE between an amide proton HN\text{H}^N and a neighboring 1H^1\text{H} , when they are within a distance less than 6 Å. In a NOESY experiment, the height and volume of the peak gives the intensity, and is related to the distance between the two atoms: Bigger peaks indicate close distance, and weak peaks indicate that the atoms are further apart and/or moving.

RDC

Residual dipolar couplings (RDCs) [2], which were first proposed in the 1980s, have emerged as an important tool in NMR to study macromolecular structure and function in a solution environment. In typical NMR experiments, the protein is in water (or water and deuterium) and it tumbles isotropically. However, if the molecules in solution exhibit a partial alignment, for example, after adding an alignment medium to the solution, this leads to incomplete averaging of spatially anisotropic dipolar couplings, and RDCs between two spins will be measured.

RDCs are complementary to NOEs; they provide global orientational information as opposed to local distance information (NOEs). RDCs also contain distance information as well as measuring the angles that are formed by a vector connecting the two atoms within a tensor axis system. In addition, both NOEs and RDCs can be used as restraints by algorithms for protein structure determination.

RDCs are defined in terms of a coordinate system called the principal order frame (POF). The general formula to extract bond orientations using RDCs for two spins aa and bb , as described in figure 3.5, is as follows:

D=μ0γaγbℏ4π2⟨ra,b3⟩⟨3cos⁡2θ−12⟩,(3.1)D = \frac{\mu_0 \gamma_a \gamma_b \hbar}{4\pi^2 \langle r_{a,b}^3 \rangle} \left\langle \frac{3 \cos^2 \theta - 1}{2} \right\rangle, \quad (3.1) where DD is the residual dipolar coupling, measured in units of Hertz, ℏ\hbar is Planck’s constant, γ\gamma is the gyromagnetic ratio, rr is the interspin distance, θ\theta is the angle between the interspin vector and the external magnetic field, and aa and bb are the spins. Then, we can simplify the equation as (see chapter 5, or [3] for details)

D=Dmax𝒗T𝑺𝒗,(3.2)D = D_{\max} \mathbf{v}^T \mathbf{S} \mathbf{v}, \quad (3.2) where DmaxD_{\max} is a physical constant, 𝒗\mathbf{v} is the orientation of the bond vector in the POF, and SS is a 3×33 \times 3 symmetric and traceless matrix, which contains 5 degrees of freedom, called the alignment tensor (or Saupe matrix). In practice, the dipolar coupling DD is measured directly, and the matrix 𝑺\mathbf{S} and the vector 𝒗\mathbf{v} are initially unknown. However, given a putative model, we can solve for 𝑺\mathbf{S} (via singular value decomposition) and back-compute RDCs. The difference between the computed and observed RDCs (RDCo−RDCc\text{RDC}_o - \text{RDC}_c) can be used to refine the model. ⟨⋅⟩\langle \cdot \rangle denotes the ensemble average. When aa and bb are covalently bonded, we typically know this distance from empirical crystal structures and replace ⟨ra,b3⟩\langle r_{a,b}^3 \rangle by a scalar distance ra,b3r_{a,b}^3 .

Figure 3.5 Extracting bond orientations using RDCs: Spins aa and bb are in the magnetic field B0B_0 ; vv and ra,br_{a,b} indicate the orientation and the distance between the spins aa and bb , respectively.

Summary

There are many NMR experiments. Let us summarize the ones we have discussed so far.

Multidimensional NMR Experiments

[HN(CO)CA+HNCA]⇒[\text{HN}(\text{CO})\text{CA}+\text{HNCA}] \Rightarrow Sequential connectivity via Cα\text{C}^\alpha and other backbone chemical shifts

HSQC,[HN(CO)CA+HNCA]⇒\text{HSQC}, [\text{HN}(\text{CO})\text{CA}+\text{HNCA}] \Rightarrow Sequential connectivity of HSQC peaks

HSQC,TOCSY⇒\text{HSQC}, \text{TOCSY} \Rightarrow Amino acid types

3JHNHα⇒^3\text{J}_{\text{HNH}\alpha} \Rightarrow J-coupling (ϕ\phi angles)

15N^{15}\text{N} NOESY ⇒\Rightarrow HN−1H\text{H}^{\text{N}-1}\text{H} distance (≤6Å\leq 6\text{\AA})

Data Type and Information Content

Chemical shifts ⇒\Rightarrow Resonance frequencies (chemical shifts)

Scalar couplings ⇒\Rightarrow Dihedral angular constraints (local)

NOEs ⇒\Rightarrow Distance constraints

Residual dipolar couplings ⇒\Rightarrow Global orientation constraints

More Applications of NMR Solvent accessibility, dynamics, protein folding assays, protein interaction assay, SAR by NMR, and others.

References

  • [1] John Cavanagh, et al.: Protein NMR Spectroscopy : Principles and Practice 2nd ed. New York: Academic Press, 2007.
  • [2] R. S. Lipsitz and N. Tjandra. Residual dipolar couplings in NMR structure analysis. Annual Review Biophysics Biomolecular Structure 2004. 33: 387–413.
  • [3] S. Grzesiek. EMBO short course on RDCs. Accessed: 2006. http://www.embl-heidelberg.de/nmr/sattler/embo/handouts/grzesiek\_RDC.pdf
  • [4] Kurt Wuthrich. NMR of Proteins and Nucleic Acids. New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1996.
  • [5] P. J. Hore. Nuclear Magnetic Resonance. New York: Oxford University Press, 1995.
  • [6] Horst Friebolin. Basic One-and Two-Dimensional NMR Spectroscopy. Weinheim: VCH Pub., 1998.