Chirality and disulfide bonds

Lesson 1.6 of Biology Primer for Computer Scientists. Download the code as a notebook.

Reflect every atom of ubiquitin through a plane. All pairwise distances stay the same. The same atoms remain close enough to make contacts, and no new steric overlaps appear. Yet the result has reversed handedness. Its fit against an ordinary biological binding partner can be completely different.

Our distance calculations have missed a property of the molecule. To detect it, we need an oriented measurement. After developing one, we will examine another constraint that a simple sequence string can omit: a covalent cross-link between distant cysteines.

Four attachments around one carbon

An amino acid's α-carbon usually carries four different groups: the backbone nitrogen, the carboxyl carbon, a hydrogen, and the side chain. Arrange those groups tetrahedrally and two mirror-image versions are possible. No rigid rotation places every group of one version on the matching group of the other. Such a center is chiral.

The pair is analogous to your hands. You can align a left thumb with a right thumb, or put the palms face to face, but you cannot rotate one hand into the other while matching every feature. To exchange handedness at the molecular center, the relative arrangement of its attachments must change.

The standard ribosomal machinery incorporates L-amino acids. Their mirror forms are called D. These names refer to a stereochemical convention; they do not directly tell us the sign of optical rotation or the handedness of a whole protein helix.

Glycine has hydrogen as its side chain, leaving two identical hydrogen attachments at Cα. Interchanging those two hydrogens produces no distinguishable molecule. Glycine is therefore achiral at Cα and has no separate L and D forms.

Loading the interactive figure…

Align alanine and its mirror image. Match nitrogen and the carboxyl carbon, then inspect the side chain and hydrogen: they occupy exchanged positions. Switch to glycine, where those two positions both hold hydrogen, and repeat the alignment.

For these amino acid drawings, the CORN rule gives a visual convention. Look toward Cα with its hydrogen pointing toward you. Follow the other groups from CO, the carboxyl or backbone carbonyl side, to R, the side chain, to N. Clockwise is L. Reversing the viewing direction reverses the apparent clockwise order, so establish the hydrogen's direction before using the rule.

D residues do occur in biology. Bacterial cell-wall peptides contain them, and specialized pathways make peptides with D residues. Some peptides acquire them through modifications after synthesis. An unexpected D residue in an ordinary ribosomal protein model therefore deserves investigation; biology's preference for L is strong without making every D-containing molecule impossible.

Handedness affects the shapes a chain can favor

A right-handed and a left-handed helix are distinct shapes even if built from achiral units. With L-amino acids, the side chains and backbone favor the familiar right-handed α-helix. Its mirror would place the same local arrangement around D residues. Forcing L residues into the opposite helical geometry changes the contacts around each residue and is generally less favorable.

That preference is not a ban on every left-handed local conformation. Glycine can adopt such geometry readily, and short left-handed regions can involve other residues. Atomic chirality and the handedness of a larger shape describe different levels of structure.

A reflected protein also needs its environment considered. Reflect the protein and its entire binding partner and their geometric complementarity survives. Reflect only the protein and its interaction with the original partner can change. A distance-based internal score cannot capture that external mismatch until the partner is included.

Use a signed volume

Take three vectors from Cα: one to N, one to the carbonyl C, and one to the first side-chain carbon, Cβ. Their scalar triple product is

V=(𝐍−𝐂α)⋅[(𝐂−𝐂α)×(𝐂β−𝐂α)].

The cross product points perpendicular to two of the vectors, and the dot product measures whether the third points along or against that direction. The magnitude is a parallelepiped volume; the sign records orientation. Translation cancels because we use differences, and a proper rotation preserves the sign. Reflection flips it.

The order of the vectors is part of the definition. Swap any two and the sign reverses. We calibrate our convention against residues of known handedness rather than calling positive “L” independently of how the expression was written.

import numpy as np
from primer import structure

def chirality_volume(residue):
    """Signed volume (ų) spanned by N, C, and Cβ around Cα; its sign is the residue's handedness."""
    n, ca, c, cb = (residue[name].coord for name in ("N", "CA", "C", "CB"))
    return float(np.dot(n - ca, np.cross(c - ca, cb - ca)))

for pdb_id in ("1UBQ", "7RSA"):
    residues = [r for r in structure(pdb_id)[0].get_residues() if r.id[0] == " "]
    volumes = [chirality_volume(r) for r in residues if "CB" in r]
    glycines = sum(r.get_resname() == "GLY" for r in residues)
    print(f"{pdb_id}: {len(volumes)} residues with Cβ, volumes from {min(volumes):.2f} to {max(volumes):.2f} ų; "
          f"{glycines} glycines skipped")
1UBQ: 70 residues with Cβ, volumes from 1.93 to 2.87 ų; 6 glycines skipped
7RSA: 121 residues with Cβ, volumes from 2.00 to 2.92 ų; 3 glycines skipped

With this order, the ordinary L residues in these two structures give positive values, a few ų each. Glycine has no Cβ and is skipped. A large negative value would indicate reversed geometry. A value near zero would indicate an almost planar arrangement of these vectors and should also prompt a geometry check.

This is information a distance matrix cannot provide by itself. A model that predicts only distances needs some further constraint to select biological handedness. Once coordinates are available, the signed-volume check costs very little.

Join two sulfurs

Cysteine's side chain ends in a thiol, –SH. Two thiols can form a disulfide, –S–S–. The sulfur atoms become covalently bonded, adding an edge to the molecular graph. If the cysteines belong to distant parts of one chain, the new edge closes a loop through that chain. A disulfide can also join two chains.

The oxidation half-reaction is

2R−SH⟶R−S−S−R+2H++2e−.

Oxidation means loss of electrons; another chemical participant accepts the electrons in the complete reaction. Reduction supplies electrons in the reverse process and restores the thiols. An oxidizing environment favors disulfide formation relative to a reducing one, though proximity and reaction kinetics also matter.

The cytosol usually maintains reducing conditions. Secreted proteins commonly form disulfides along their route out of a cell and keep them outside. Some internal compartments also favor disulfide formation, so “inside the cell” is too broad a label to decide the chemistry. The cysteines must also be suitably placed; their mere presence does not imply a bond.

A sulfur–sulfur distance near 2.0 Å is strong structural evidence for a disulfide. This is much shorter than an ordinary nonbonded sulfur contact, whose radius sum is about 3.6 Å. In PDB atom names, the cysteine sulfur is SG, pronounced S-gamma.

Imagine a long string with two marked points. Join those points with a short staple. Many previously possible shapes are now inaccessible because the marked points cannot separate. The same happens to a polypeptide with an intact disulfide.

A compact folded structure may already put those cysteines close together. The cross-link then restricts the unfolded chain more strongly than it restricts the folded chain. Unfolding gains less conformational entropy, making it less favorable. This explanation compares folded and unfolded states with the disulfide intact in both. If the bond is also reduced during the comparison, the chemistry of breaking it must be included separately.

A well-placed cross-link can therefore stabilize a protein without greatly changing its folded coordinates. A badly placed one can strain the native structure or prevent correct folding. The outcome depends on which conformations the new constraint removes.

Ribonuclease A has eight cysteines forming four disulfides. Measure their geometry:

from itertools import combinations
from Bio.PDB.vectors import calc_dihedral
from primer import structure

cysteines = [r for r in structure("7RSA")[0]["A"] if r.get_resname() == "CYS"]
print(f"{len(cysteines)} cysteines:", [c.id[1] for c in cysteines])
for a, b in combinations(cysteines, 2):
    ss = a["SG"] - b["SG"]
    if ss < 2.5:
        chi3 = calc_dihedral(*(x.get_vector() for x in (a["CB"], a["SG"], b["SG"], b["CB"])))
        print(f"Cys {a.id[1]:>3}–Cys {b.id[1]:<3}  S–S {ss:.2f} Å   Cα–Cα {a['CA'] - b['CA']:.2f} Å   χ3 {np.degrees(chi3):+.0f}°")
8 cysteines: [26, 40, 58, 65, 72, 84, 95, 110]
Cys  26–Cys 84   S–S 2.00 Å   Cα–Cα 5.61 Å   χ3 -80°
Cys  40–Cys 95   S–S 2.01 Å   Cα–Cα 5.49 Å   χ3 -82°
Cys  58–Cys 110  S–S 1.98 Å   Cα–Cα 5.99 Å   χ3 -83°
Cys  65–Cys 72   S–S 1.97 Å   Cα–Cα 5.18 Å   χ3 +109°

The partners are 26–84, 40–95, 58–110, and 65–72. Three links connect widely separated sequence positions. Their S–S bonds are near the expected length, while their surrounding angles and torsions let the chain approach those bonds from different directions.

Trace the chain between each disulfide's two cysteines. Switch to the N-to-C coloring and follow the 65–72 pair first, then a longer loop such as 26–84. Imagine unfolding the chain while keeping each sulfur pair joined: the long loops can move, but their endpoints cannot separate.

Open 7RSA in Mol*

Eight cysteines have 7×5×3×1=105 possible complete pairings. To count them, choose a partner for the first cysteine in seven ways, then a partner for the next unpaired cysteine in five ways, and continue. The four bonds in the native protein are therefore more information than “eight cysteines are present.” Folding and disulfide formation must arrive at a compatible pairing, sometimes with help from enzymes that rearrange incorrect links.

When the right bonds found the right partners

Christian Anfinsen's group used ribonuclease to test how sequence could specify a working fold. Urea disrupted its folded structure, and a reducing reagent broke its disulfides. If the sulfurs were then allowed to re-form bonds while the protein remained in concentrated urea, the result was a mixture of scrambled pairings with only about 1% of the native enzyme's activity.

The telling step came next. Remove the urea and allow disulfide exchange with a small amount of a thiol reagent. The scrambled material could recover the native protein. The links had to be able to rearrange for the chain to reach its favorable structure.Anfinsen describes the experiment in his 1972 Nobel lecture.

The practical lesson is visible in our 105-pairing count. Oxidizing a protein is not enough; the connections must be compatible with its fold. A sample can have the expected sequence and four disulfides yet perform poorly because the partners are wrong. An activity measurement and a connectivity measurement answer different questions about that same sample.

Check yourself

A reflected protein passes every pairwise-distance check performed on the original. What happens to its signed volumes? Would one particular negative volume be meaningful without knowing the vector order?

Reasoning

Every signed volume changes sign. A negative value only acquires a stereochemical meaning after the vector order is fixed and calibrated. Comparing the same definition before and after reflection reveals the reversal directly.

Can a chain of glycines form a chiral shape? Explain why this does not give an individual glycine an L or D identity.

Reasoning

Yes; a helix is a chiral arrangement of the chain. Each glycine's Cα still has two identical hydrogen attachments and no chiral center. The global shape can have handedness even when its individual units do not, and opposite helical shapes are equally allowed by the units' local stereochemistry alone.

A protein has six cysteines but only two disulfides. What should you inspect before deciding that the remaining cysteines indicate an error?

Reasoning

Inspect their sulfur distances and local surroundings. The remaining cysteines may be ordinary free thiols or may participate in other chemistry, such as metal binding. If their sulfurs are near a covalent S–S distance, check whether the bond was simply omitted from an annotation. A count alone cannot assign partners.

A new disulfide leaves the folded coordinates almost unchanged but removes many conformations of the unfolded chain. Predict its entropic contribution to stability. What could reverse that prediction?

Reasoning

It reduces the entropy gained on unfolding, favoring the folded state if other contributions are similar. Strain in the folded structure, unfavorable new contacts, or an incompatible pairing could outweigh that benefit. A cross-link is a constraint whose value depends on where it is placed.