Electronegativity and polarity
A water molecule has ten protons and ten electrons. Its net charge is zero. Yet it turns when an ion approaches, placing its oxygen toward a positive ion and its hydrogens toward a negative one. Overall neutrality clearly does not mean that every part of the molecule presents the same electrical surface.
The missing information is where the electrons spend their time. Covalent bonding shares them, but sharing need not be equal.
Unequal sharing
Electronegativity describes an atom's tendency to attract shared electron density in a bond. Oxygen attracts it more strongly than hydrogen, so an O–H bond has extra electron density toward oxygen and a deficit toward hydrogen. We mark those ends δ⁻ and δ⁺. The δ indicates partial charge, distinct from the whole-number net charge of an ion.
Approximate Pauling electronegativities are enough for our first comparisons:
| Element | Electronegativity |
|---|---|
| Hydrogen | 2.20 |
| Carbon | 2.55 |
| Sulfur | 2.58 |
| Nitrogen | 3.04 |
| Oxygen | 3.44 |
The ordering predicts that O–H and N–H bonds are polar, with positive hydrogens. C–H and C–S have smaller differences and are much less polar. There is no abrupt threshold at which polarity switches on. Electronegativity differences supply a qualitative guide; the surrounding bonds and electron delocalization also influence the actual distribution.
This gives a useful first pass through a protein drawing. A hydrocarbon branch contains weakly polar C–H bonds. Add an OH and you create an end that can interact strongly with water. Replace that OH with a carboxylate and you create a group that usually carries a full negative charge near neutral pH. A few atoms can change a side chain's preferred surroundings.
Giving the distribution numbers
A force field is a mathematical model that assigns energies to molecular arrangements. Many common force fields approximate electrostatics by placing a partial charge on each atom. The charges are parameters chosen to reproduce aspects of molecular electrostatics and measured behavior. They are not tiny labels that an experiment reads directly from individual atoms.
One common water model, TIP3P, assigns oxygen −0.834 and each hydrogen +0.417, in units of the elementary charge . Add them:
The molecule is neutral, with substantial positive and negative regions. Those regions occupy different positions, so a nearby charge interacts differently with each one.
Compare water, a peptide group, and the charged side-chain tips. Add the displayed charges before looking at the total. Then inspect the outermost atoms: these are the regions another molecule can approach most closely.
Now inspect lysine. In the example parameter set, the nitrogen at the end of its side chain is itself slightly negative, although the side chain carries a net positive charge. This is not an inconsistency. Its attached hydrogens are positive, and the charge is distributed over neighboring atoms as well. The formal + sign in the chemical drawing and the nitrogen's force-field partial charge are different kinds of accounting.
lys_tip = {"CE": 0.21, "HE1": 0.05, "HE2": 0.05, "NZ": -0.30, "HZ1": 0.33, "HZ2": 0.33, "HZ3": 0.33}
asp_tip = {"CB": -0.28, "HB1": 0.09, "HB2": 0.09, "CG": 0.62, "OD1": -0.76, "OD2": -0.76}
peptide = {"C": 0.51, "O": -0.51, "N": -0.47, "H": 0.31, "CA": 0.07, "HA": 0.09} # one backbone unit
for name, group in [("lysine tip", lys_tip), ("aspartate tip", asp_tip), ("backbone unit", peptide)]:
print(f"{name:14} net charge {sum(group.values()):+.2f}")
lysine tip net charge +1.00 aspartate tip net charge -1.00 backbone unit net charge +0.00
The chosen lysine tip sums to +1 and the aspartate group to −1. The backbone unit sums to zero. For lysine, notice that the three H charges and N charge alone sum to +0.69; the remaining +0.31 is assigned to the adjacent carbon and its hydrogens. Taking only one atom's parameter would miss both the total and the geometry of the distribution.
Different force fields can distribute the same group's charge differently. A simulation must use a consistent parameter set; choosing each atom's charge independently would destroy the relationships for which the model was fitted.
Geometry can cancel polarity
For a neutral molecule, the dipole moment is
It measures the separation of positive and negative charge as a vector. Translating all coordinates adds the same vector multiplied by , which is zero for a neutral molecule. Its dipole therefore does not depend on where we put the origin.For a charged molecule, this expression does depend on the origin. That is one reason to distinguish net charge from dipole moment.
Imagine carbon dioxide, O=C=O. Each oxygen attracts electron density from carbon, but the molecule is linear and symmetric. The two equal contributions point in opposite directions and cancel. Water's O–H bonds meet at about 104.5°, so their contributions do not cancel. Symmetry explains the difference before we calculate a number.
The following cell constructs the two geometries and evaluates their dipole magnitudes. A dipole of one elementary charge separated by one ångström is about 4.803 debye, the conventional unit.
import numpy as np
DEBYE_PER_E_ANGSTROM = 4.803
def dipole(charges, coords):
"""Magnitude in debye of sum(q_i * r_i); charges in e, coordinates in Å."""
mu = (np.asarray(charges)[:, None] * np.asarray(coords)).sum(axis=0)
return np.linalg.norm(mu) * DEBYE_PER_E_ANGSTROM
# TIP3P water: O–H 0.9572 Å, H–O–H 104.52°, charges −0.834 and +0.417
half = np.radians(104.52) / 2
water = [[0, 0, 0], [0.9572 * np.sin(half), 0.9572 * np.cos(half), 0], [-0.9572 * np.sin(half), 0.9572 * np.cos(half), 0]]
print(f"water: {dipole([-0.834, 0.417, 0.417], water):.2f} D")
# CO2: linear, C=O 1.16 Å; charges from a common CO2 model (C +0.651, each O −0.3255)
co2 = [[0, 0, 0], [1.16, 0, 0], [-1.16, 0, 0]]
print(f"carbon dioxide: {dipole([0.651, -0.3255, -0.3255], co2):.2f} D")
water: 2.35 D carbon dioxide: 0.00 D
CO₂ gives zero and TIP3P water gives about 2.35 D. An isolated real water molecule has a dipole near 1.85 D. TIP3P is intended to model liquid water, where neighboring molecules alter one another's electron distributions; its fixed parameters incorporate some effects of that environment.
A zero dipole does not erase every electrical interaction. CO₂ still has positive and negative regions, and at short distances another molecule can distinguish them. Dipole moment is one summary of a charge distribution, not a complete replacement for it.
Read a protein as a chemical surface
The repeating peptide backbone contains a carbonyl, C=O, and usually an N–H. Oxygen carries a partial negative charge and the hydrogen a partial positive charge. The backbone therefore has a repeating polar pattern, even when every side chain in a stretch is hydrophobic.
This creates a problem when the chain folds inward. Carbon-rich side chains can pack together, but the attached backbone brings polar groups with it. Those groups can make hydrogen bonds to other parts of the chain, or to water that remains in a cavity. Helices and sheets arrange many of these groups into repeating hydrogen-bond patterns. Their geometry will make more sense once we understand what each buried group can interact with.
Side chains add local variations. Alanine's methyl group is small and nonpolar. Serine adds an OH. Aspartate has a carboxylate, usually negative near pH 7. Lysine has a long hydrocarbon section ending in a usually positive amino group. Calling lysine “charged” summarizes its behavior, but the chain of carbons leading to the charge can still make nonpolar contacts.
Some residues especially resist one-word classification. Tyrosine has a large aromatic ring and a polar OH. Tryptophan has a large ring system with one hydrogen-bond donor. Cysteine's sulfur is polarizable, can participate in weak interactions, and can lose a proton. We will classify whole residues in chapter 2 while continuing to inspect the individual groups when a local contact matters.
As a rough inventory, count nitrogen and oxygen atoms in ubiquitin's backbone and side chains:
from collections import Counter
from primer import structure
atoms = [a for a in structure("1UBQ")[0].get_atoms() if a.get_parent().id[0] == " "]
backbone = {"N", "CA", "C", "O"}
count = Counter(("backbone" if a.get_id() in backbone else "side chain", a.element in "NO") for a in atoms)
for part in ("backbone", "side chain"):
polar, nonpolar = count[(part, True)], count[(part, False)]
print(f"{part:10}: {polar} N/O atoms, {nonpolar} C/S atoms ({polar / (polar + nonpolar):.0%} polar)")
backbone : 152 N/O atoms, 152 C/S atoms (50% polar) side chain: 71 N/O atoms, 227 C/S atoms (24% polar)
The code uses element identity as a proxy, not a complete test of polarity. About half the backbone's heavy atoms are N or O, while the side chains contain proportionally more carbon. This makes the backbone's hydrogen-bonding problem hard to avoid: every folded region must accommodate these repeated polar groups along with the variable side chains.
Check yourself
CCl₄ has four polar C–Cl bonds arranged tetrahedrally. CH₃Cl has only one chlorine. Predict which has zero dipole by symmetry, then explain why this does not imply that chlorine has lost its partial charge.
Reasoning
CCl₄ has four equal bond contributions that cancel by tetrahedral symmetry. CH₃Cl lacks that symmetry and has a nonzero dipole. Cancellation concerns the vector sum over positions; each bond can remain polar and still contribute to local electrical interactions.
A lysine nitrogen has a force-field partial charge of −0.30. Someone predicts that it will repel a nearby aspartate side chain. What additional information is needed?
Reasoning
The other charges and their positions. Lysine's positive hydrogens can approach an aspartate oxygen closely, and the complete lysine group has net charge +1. The electrostatic energy is a sum over atom pairs. A single atom's sign cannot substitute for that sum.
Translate every atom of a neutral molecule by a vector . Show why its dipole stays unchanged. What extra term remains if the molecule has net charge ?
Reasoning
The new dipole is . For a neutral molecule the added term is zero. For an ion it is , so the quoted dipole requires an origin convention.
A protein segment contains only leucine and alanine side chains. Is every atom in that segment nonpolar? Predict what the segment must accommodate if it folds into a water-excluding core.
Reasoning
Its backbone still contains carbonyl oxygens and N–H groups. Burying the segment removes many interactions with water, so favorable buried arrangements usually provide hydrogen-bond partners for those backbone groups. Side-chain hydrophobicity does not eliminate backbone polarity.